Deer Wars
Science, Tradition, and the Battle Over Managing Whitetails in Pennsylvania
328 pages | 39 illustrations | 7 x 8.5 | 2006
Cloth edition is not available
ISBN 978-0-271-02885-9 | paper: $33.95 tr
A Keystone Book®
In 1931, when Charlie May was a teenager, deer were a rare thingin Pennsylvania. When one of his classmates burst into their one-roomschoolhouse in Schuylkill County saying that he had seen a deertrack - not a deer, mind you, but just a track - their teacher tookeveryone out into the snow to see it.
Things have certainly changed in the decades since then. Sportsmenand biologists brought deer back in a big way in the early 20thcentury, growing the herd until it was considered to be among thetwo or three biggest in the nation. Indeed, May's son, who retiredfrom the Pennsylvania Game Commission as a wildlife conservationofficer in 2005, spent most of his career dealing not with a shortageof deer, but with an abundance of whitetails. That abundance - evenoverabundance, to hear some tell the story - has had severe consequences,though.
You can have too much of a good thing when it comes to white-taileddeer, say some of the farmers, foresters, bird watchers, auto insuranceagents, biologists, and even hunters who have to deal with the deerthat roam Pennsylvania from the big woods of the northern tier tothe suburbs around Pittsburgh and the parks within Philadelphia.All agree they want deer in Pennsylvania, but in manageable numbersin the right places.
There have been and will continue to be problems until that balanceis achieved. That's because deer, though beautiful, can also bedevastating. "Deer are second only to humans in their impacton a forest ecosystem," says Dr. Gary Alt, who headed the GameCommission's deer management section until the constant battlingover whitetails drove him to quit. "They can, and will, dictatewhat other animals will survive there."
Knowing that is one thing. Being able to do something about it -especially in Pennsylvania, where deer hunting traditions are asdeeply rooted as 100-year-old white oak - is something else. A numberof people, some Game Commission officials included, say they deerherd has been mismanaged for 80 years. That must change, they say,if deer populations are to finally be brought into balance withtheir habitat and if hunting as we know it is to survive.
Can that battle be won? People across the state and the nation arewaiting to see. Virtually every state east of the Mississippi isdealing with this same issue - too many deer for the available habitatand a public that's come to believe having that many deer is notonly OK, it's desirable. Pennsylvania may be the model for solving that problem.
"From the field notes of Emil Johnson, state game warden for Warren County in the 1920s, to recollections of Dick Gerstell, Game Commission research director in the 1930s, to a fitting tribute to the work and writings of Roger Latham in the 1950s, Frye knits together a very informative and readable in-depth history. He also does a credible job of reviewing the other contemporary issues facing deer managers in Pennsylvania and elsewhere, including suburban/urban deer management, chronic wasting disease and deer farming.
In sum, Deer Wars is a carefully researched, comprehensive, 328-page, softcover history of one of the wildlife profession's most vexing sagas. It is well worth reading by anyone interested in deer management, wildlife management history, human dimensions of wildlife or with a Pennsylvania hunting license." —Outdoor News Bulletin of the Wildlife Management Institute
"It might be a little late now to find a copy to take to deer camp, but every Pennsylvania deer hunter should get -- and read: Deer Wars; Science, Tradition, and the Battle Over Managing Whitetails in Pennsylvania, a new book by Bob Frye. Not because the book will help those who still have a deer tag get a buck, but because this work offers a clear presentation of the history, lore and complexity of living with deer in the modern world. It's the book our state needed decades ago. Deer Wars examines all aspects of the questions: How many deer should Pennsylvania have? Why? And who says so?
Throughout the book's 305 pages, he writes about deer and deer issues with a native Western Pennsylvania outdoorsman's insight and affection for whitetails, tempered with keen journalistic timing and logical organization of the material.
Too often, the various sides in deer debates have tended to see Pennsylvania's landscape as static. But Frye succeeds in communicating, more than anything else, the fundamental changes that have occurred in the state's ecology, economy, land use and politics that have come together to put deer and humans in conflict." —Ben Moyer, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
"If I had the power to do it, I'd make Deer Wars mandatory reading for every deer hunter, anti-hunter, wildlife manager, farmer, forester and environmentalist in the state. It's that good." —Christian Berg, The Morning Call
"I write for a living and read a lot. I've seen the good and the bad. It is not often a book gets my juices flowing. But from the instant I picked up Deer Wars, I was hooked. Bob Frye, the author, did an excellent job describing the never-ending battle that surrounds Pennsylvania's deer-management strategies.
The book, which the Penn State University Press released earlier this year, goes to great lengths detailing the history of the state's deer herd. It gives a precise timeline of how we got where we are today, and does an even better job showing the reader the wide impact the deer population has on our ecosystem." —Andy Snyder, The York Dispatch"At the top of the list, Bob Frye, outdoor editor for the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, has taken a deep, well-informed, expert-rich look at the ongoing "Deer Wars" in Pennsylvania.
He's been covering the story since before the latest chapters began to be written six or seven years ago and has interviewed hundreds of hunters, biologists, researchers, land managers and others on this subject....As the subtitle suggests, Frye really does take the reader far into the "Science, Tradition and the Battle over Managing Whitetails in Pennsylvania." —Marcus Schneck, Harrisburg Patriot News
"Hunters and non-hunters alike should take the opportunity to read this book. Non-hunters stand to learn about the problems uncontrolled wild animal populations can create as well as the purpose and role hunting plays in managing those populations and problems. Hunters - when you’re finished you’ll have a much better understanding of deer management as it’s practiced today, whether or not you agree with it. More importantly, it will help you determine if you truly are a conservationist, or simply just a hunter." —Ted Onufrak, President, The Pennsylvania Federation of Sportsmen’s Clubs, Inc.
"Bob has interviewed an amazing array of characters on all sides of the deer management issue—in fact, I can’t think of any major player he hasn’t interviewed. In his unbiased, reporter-style coverage, he almost never takes a position; he just reports what other people say, often providing quotations from others with conflicting views. This book certainly represents the most comprehensive documentation of the history of deer management in Pennsylvania." —Dr. Gary Alt, Former Pennsylvania Game Commission Deer Management Section Supervisor, from the foreword
"A well balanced, carefully documented, must read for anyone involved in the politics of modern day wildlife management in Pennsylvania" —John C. Oliver, former President, Western Pennsylvania Conservancy and former Secretary, Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources
"True to his award-winning style, Bob has produced a meticulously researched, superbly written, and often humorous and emotional exposé about Pennsylvania’s premier game animal. This prodigious book should be on the shelves of every serious conservationist and wildlife scholar." —Roxane Palone, Vice-President, Pennsylvania Game Commission
"Go to any barber shop in Pennsylvania and you will discover at least one expert and many strongly held opinions on deer management. I urge fellow hunters and wildlife enthusiasts to read this well-written and fascinating book that explores the checkered history of deer management in Pennsylvania." — Larry J. Schweiger, President and CEO, National Wildlife Federation
Bob Frye is an award winning outdoors journalist and the Outdoors Editor for the Tribune-Review.
Contents
Foreword
Acknowledgments
1 How Much Is Enough?
2 The Nature of Overabundance
3 When You Can’t See the Forest for the Deer
4 Too Many Mouths in the Grocery Aisle
5 At Home in the ’Burbs
6 Bambi Versus the Buick
7 Heroes or Goats?
8 Questions and Answers
9 Getting to the Point of Managing Deer Correctly
10 In the Eye of the Storm
11 A Wild Card in the Deer Management Deck
12 A Look to the Future
Index